BookCrossing vs Read it, Swap it.

Of course there isn't really a contest, but I've just been introduced to "Read it Swap it" by another BXer. Both have similar purposes but operate differently.

Both pursuits are 'free' but BXing is global whereas RiSi is UK only, BXing allows you to reduce your read/unwanted bookpile in a magnanimous way (although you can initiate swaps between members), RiSi is about swapping books with its members, so you don't actually reduce your stockpile (unless you trade smaller, thinner books - or write-off those who default). That raises the next issue.

RiSi has a Feedback system, like eBay, so members can avoid dealing with those who don't keep their side of the bargain - I mean, with the changes (hike) in postal charges, this could be significant - at least leaving books around in public places doesn't incur postal charges. RiSi requires the swapper to state the condition of the book from drop-down menus, again telling porkies here would be revealed in the feedback, and like eBay, it tracks the progress of the swap until completion.

Once you agree a swap, your book automatically disappears from your list. Like BXing, booklists are linked to Amazon, so the thumbnail cover art is displayed, but additionally, there is a direct link to the details/synopsis too.

Unlike BXing, once the swap is completed, there is no way of knowing what happens to your book afterwards, unless the book is registered with BXing and the swapee is willing to journal it. If your potential swaps do have a BCID or bookplate stuck inside, you should declare this in the 'Book Description'. So if you are an avid reader - join both!

Happy reading